Why do we keep falling for people who are bad for us?
Science has some answers — and they’re both fascinating and frustrating. From how your childhood shapes your “type” to why your brain literally gets high on new love, here’s what psychologists, relationship experts, and neuroscientists have uncovered about why attraction so often leads us astray — and what you can do about it.
1. Your Childhood Shapes Who You’re Drawn To
Psychologists have long shown that our early attachment patterns play a huge role in who we find attractive as adults. If your caregivers were inconsistent — sometimes loving, sometimes distant — you might unconsciously be drawn to partners who recreate that same push-pull dynamic.
Example: Ever notice how you keep dating people who blow hot and cold? That’s not random. Your brain finds “familiar chaos” comforting, even if it hurts.
Your takeaway: Notice patterns, not just people.
-
Write down the last three people you were seriously attracted to.
-
List the top three traits they shared.
-
Then ask yourself: “Do these traits remind me of how love felt growing up?”
Awareness won’t instantly change who you’re attracted to, but it gives you power to choose differently.
2. Your Brain Loves the Reward Chase
Attraction is fueled by dopamine — the same brain chemical tied to gambling and risk-taking. When someone is inconsistent or hard to “get,” your brain treats it like a slot machine. The unpredictability keeps you hooked.
Example: You wait hours for a text back, they finally reply, and suddenly you feel euphoric. That’s dopamine at work — and why “bad texters” can feel magnetic.
Your takeaway: Break the dopamine loop.
-
If someone’s inconsistent, create space instead of chasing.
-
Wait to respond sometimes, and let them initiate more.
-
Ask yourself: “If this person were eager and available, would I still be this interested?”
This forces your brain to separate true compatibility from the thrill of unpredictability.
3. Physical Chemistry Hijacks Rational Thinking
When you meet someone and feel an intense spark, your brain floods with oxytocin and phenylethylamine — chemicals that mimic the effects of mild narcotics. It’s why red flags seem invisible in the early stages of dating.
Example: You overlook that they cancel plans last-minute or avoid talking about commitment, because the physical connection feels overpowering.
Your takeaway: Slow down the timeline.
-
Delay physical intimacy until you’ve spent real time together.
-
Schedule “non-romantic” hangouts — brunch, errands, workouts — to see how they show up outside the high-stakes context.
-
Chemistry without compatibility leads to heartbreak; create situations that test both.
4. We Mistake Familiarity for Compatibility
Research shows we’re unconsciously drawn to what feels familiar, even when it’s unhealthy. If chaos, drama, or emotional unavailability feel “normal,” you may confuse that feeling with passion.
Example: You meet someone calm, consistent, and emotionally available — and you feel… bored. That’s not boredom. That’s peace — it just feels unfamiliar.
Your takeaway: Redefine what “attractive” means.
-
Give people three dates before making up your mind, even if there’s no initial spark.
-
Notice how you feel around them: safe, heard, respected — these are better predictors of long-term happiness than butterflies.
-
Attraction can grow with security and consistency; give it a chance.
5. We Ignore Values While Chasing Vibes
Psychologists say one of the biggest reasons we end up with the wrong partners is because we prioritize chemistry over compatibility. You can adore someone’s sense of humor or energy, but if your core values clash, the relationship will hit a wall.
Example: You love adventure, travel, and new experiences. They want a quiet, rooted life. No amount of attraction fixes that mismatch.
Your takeaway: Do the “future test.”
-
Ask yourself: “If nothing about this person changed, could I see myself building a life with them?”
-
Talk about non-romantic topics early: family, finances, lifestyle, values.
-
Physical sparks fade, but aligned values sustain connection.
Take Action: Attraction isn’t random — it’s shaped by your brain, your experiences, and your patterns.
The next time you feel pulled toward someone who isn’t right for you, pause and ask yourself: Am I chasing chemistry, or building a real connection?
Focus on consistency, alignment, and emotional safety — and you’ll stop repeating old patterns and start choosing love that truly lasts.
